Craig Mazin denies Abby appearance in The Last of Us finale

Having said that, another conjecture about Abby and her role in The Last of Us Season 2 looms large - her casting. The Last of Us Part II offered a narrative stage where Abby shares the spotlight with Ellie, her role rife with significance. As the plans to adapt the events of the second game across multiple seasons become clear, the question of Abby's casting takes center stage. Showrunners Mazin and Neil Druckmann have set the fandom ablaze with anticipation as the crucial casting choice remains shrouded in mystery.

Names such as Shannon Berry and Katy O'Brian have surfaced in the rumor mill, further adding fuel to the fire. However, in the same podcast, Mazin quelled the growing whispers, stating "No one has been cast" as Abby yet. Evidently, the casting process remains enigmatic, with audition scripts from the second video game reportedly being used before the writer's strike.

Then again, the choice to use the word "no one" can be considered that Mazin is hinting at the Game of Thrones actress, Maisie Williams.

It certainly wouldn't be the first time the 26-year-old English actress found herself up for a potential role in The Last of Us. And though she'd have to do quite a bit of bulking up to do Abby's role justice, The Last of Us has shown that it's willing to take certain creative liberties with the source material.

Speculations aside, the casting of The Last of Us has been stellar so far. Bella Ramsey and Pedro Pascal have embodied their roles with a compelling authenticity that has won the hearts of the audience. The casting of Abby is expected to hold the same weight, if not more, given her narrative importance in the second part of the game. As fans grapple with conjectures, wishes, and debates, the decision hangs in the air, an intriguing mystery awaiting its grand reveal.