Square Enix is disappointed with Marvel's Avengers

Marvel's Avengers publishers thought that Crystal Dynamics was a mismatch for the game but still believed that the approach was correct.

It's no secret that Marvel's Avengers hasn't done exactly as Square Enix had hoped. Even if the publisher didn't outright admit it, a game that's based on a franchise worth billions of dollars should've done better than Marvel's Avengers.

Marvel's Avengers should probably turn Square Enix away from doing more Games as a Service titles going forward.

However, while Marvel's Avengers didn't do as bad as it appears - we defended the game in a recent article - it appears that Square Enix thinks that Marvel's Avengers was a disappointment.

QUICKTAKE: View the short-form version of this article or scroll to keep reading.

Square Enix president is unhappy with Marvel's Avengers

Square Enix didn't outright pin the blame on Crystal Dynamics, but the statement says a lot about the company's thoughts on why the game failed.

According to Square Enix's 2021 Annual Report, company president Yosuke Matsuda explained that the company was not happy with the result of Marvel's Avengers. In addition, Matsuda appeared to imply that Crystal Dynamics was not a good fit for Marvel's Avengers and its Games as a Service approach. To quote, Matsuda said that Square Enix should "select game designs that mesh with the unique attributes and tastes of our studios and development teams."

It's hard to say what Square Enix meant specifically, but it's hard not to come up with the conclusion that it's blaming Crystal Dynamics for Marvel's Avengers shortcomings. To be fair, Crystal Dynamics probably had no say about the Games as a Service model. The longtime Tomb Raider studio hadn't worked on a title that had a Games as a Service model before. Because of this, Crystal Dynamics probably was not well-equipped to handle Marvel's Avengers development. To make matters worse, the Games as a Service model has a bad reputation.

MORE:  Sackboy: A Big Adventure might be coming to PC via Steam

With that said, Crystal Dynamics is doing everything it can to salvage Marvel's Avengers. Spider-Man is coming to the PlayStation version of the game on November 30 and who knows what else Crystal Dynamics has in store for the game in the future?

It does appear that future Marvel games are avoiding the live-service model like the plague.

If we're being honest, Marvel's Avengers isn't a failure. It's quite successful. The single-player campaign captured the spirit of the characters and the missions were spot-on. The only problem with Marvel's Avengers is when it tried to get players to stick around after the credits rolled. Marvel's Avengers shouldn't have been designed as a live service game. Thankfully, Eidos-Montreal learned from this mistake with the more beloved Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy.

Only time will tell if Square Enix and Crystal Dynamics will continue supporting Marvel's Avengers in 2022 and beyond. It will also be interesting how Crystal Dynamics responds to Square Enix effectively throwing the studio under the bus.

Ray Ampoloquio
Ray is based in the Philippines. He is a lifelong gamer and a PC hardware enthusiast. He builds and repairs laptops and computers for friends and family in his spare time. You can find Ray on Twitter.