Risen, a non-official successor to the old Gothic and Gothic 2, has been released 3 days ago (2nd October, though some countries are still before release date). Since then there were many reviews - most of them are positive (PC version) but some are not too positive(Xbox360 version). As you can see in this screenshot Pyranha Bytes really cares about console players. Gorath on RPG Watch has posted a nice list with links to reviews. Check it here and there, there and here.